You will see that those who are born with strength and courage are often clumsy
and not very intelligent, while the weaker ones often have a stronger instinct and are more
judicious and skillful than those to whom nature has given other advantages. You understand well
that according to this law, nature, having granted more strength and courage to men than to
women, has given us more spirit and judgement.
But once again, Erinna, let's assume they have as much as we do provided they
also recognize that we have as much as they do. You could tell me that even if
I obtain the consent of all men on the admission of our judgement, I would not still be able to
persuade you that the knowledge of letters suits a woman, for by a
practice established by men, studies are as forbidden to us as war is. Making
verses amounts to the same as fighting battles, if we listen to them well. In truth, it seems that
what is permitted to us today should be banned. What, Erinna, we have a
brilliant imagination, a sharp mind, an advantageous memory, a sound judgement, and
we are only permitted to use them to set our hair and search for the
ornaments that can add something to our beauty? No, Erinna, it would be to waste
needlessly the favors we have received from nature. Those who are born with eyes
capable of conquest should not be content with these subterfuges to enhance the
charms of nature. It's to devalue our mind to indulge it all our life
to such tasks. It could even be said that if things were arranged as they should be,
the study of the beautiful letters should be more permitted to women than to men. Given
that they have the responsibility to govern the universe, that some are kings, others
provincial governors, some priests and others magistrates, and all generally masters of
their families, and consequently occupied either by public affairs, or by their own, they
undoubtedly have little time to devote to this art. They must steal this time from their commitments,
from their friends or from themselves.
But for us, our leisure and our retreat offer us all the ease we
could wish for. We take nothing from the people or from ourselves. On the contrary, we
enrich ourselves without impoverishing others. We glorify our homeland by becoming ourselves-
glorious, and without compromising anyone, we accumulate a lot of fame.
It seems fair, since we leave the ascendant to men, they at least leave us
the freedom to know all the things of which our mind is capable. The desire for good and for
knowledge should not be forbidden to us, and practicing it is not criminal. The gods have created nothing
useless in nature, each thing follows the order that has been given to it. The sun illuminates and
warms the universe, the earth offers us flowers and fruits each year, the sea gives us
all its riches, rivers irrigate our meadows, forests provide us with their shade, and
in the end, all things contribute to society. In these circumstances, why should it
be that we alone are the only rebels and ungrateful towards the gods?


155